André Dallaire

André Dallaire (born 1961) is a Canadian man who attempted to assassinate Canadian prime minister Jean Chrétien in 1995. Dallaire claimed that he heard voices that led him to break into the 24 Sussex Drive residence. At trial, Justice Paul Bélanger agreed with Dallaire's earlier diagnosis of paranoid schizophrenia and found Dallaire guilty of attempted murder, but not criminally responsible.

View of 24 Sussex Drive from Rockliffe Park lookout, 2004

Biography

Born in Longueuil, Quebec, Dallaire was diagnosed as having paranoid schizophrenia at sixteen years of age. He had quit his job at a Montreal convenience store on October 25, 1995, removing all the money out of the cash register and walking off mid-shift. On October 30, his sister reported receiving a letter from him that had been postmarked in Ottawa.

The break-in

At 02:10 UTC−5 on November 5, 1995, Dallaire arrived outside 24 Sussex Drive and spent the next 20 minutes throwing stones onto the grounds and waving at security cameras while carrying a pocket knife alternatively described as three or five inches in length (7.5 or 12.5 cm).

He then climbed the fence and strode over to the house, where he smashed a glass door and entered, wandering around the basement and ground floor for 30 minutes before heading to the Chrétiens' bedroom, where he was confronted by Chrétien's wife, Aline, as he was pulling on his gloves. Aline hurried back into the bedroom and locked the door, rousing her husband, who initially dismissed her story as "just a dream", while she dialled the RCMP officers stationed outside the house. It was reported that either Aline or Jean brandished an Inuit stone sculpture of a loon in case Dallaire broke through the door.

Dallaire did not attempt to break down the door, and waited for the police to arrive. Controversially, it took roughly seven minutes for the police to respond to Aline's desperate call about an intruder trying to kill the Prime Minister, in part because the first officer to respond had forgotten his key to the residence.

Legal events

Dallaire was kept in a group home for the duration of the trial. Expert witness Dominique Bourget, a psychiatrist with the Royal Ottawa Hospital, testified that Dallaire viewed himself as a "secret agent" avenging the loss of sovereigntist forces in the 1995 Quebec referendum, and that he believed killing the Prime Minister would cause him to "become a hero for the nation".

His travel during the trial was not restricted, so long as he was accompanied at all times by a worker from the group home. He was formally charged with attempted murder, breaking and entering, possession of a weapon and being unlawfully in a dwelling. His defence counsel was John Hale.^{[citation needed]}

The trial also brought to light the security camera footage of Dallaire freely roaming the property, while RCMP officers should have been monitoring the cameras. Ultimately, four officers were suspended for several months, while three supervisors were reassigned. Reform Party MP and former RCMP constable Jack Ramsay remarked "among RCMP officers that the 24 Sussex job is one of the most boring—and until last fall the force did not dispatch its best people to carry out the job."

Dallaire was found guilty, but deemed not responsible because of mental incompetence.

Aftermath

In 1998, Dallaire spoke to the media, apologizing for his prior behaviour, and reassuring the Canadian public that he was now on medication that controlled his actions, and that he hoped the Chrétiens could forgive his actions.

After about a year, Dallaire was given a conditional discharge, and sent to live in an Ottawa group home.

In 1998, an intoxicated man was found on the grounds of the Prime Minister's residence, raising questions about the security upgrade undertaken since Dallaire's intrusion.

Reporters revisited the 1995 Dallaire breach after two political attacks in 2014: an August break-in at the home of Liberal Party leader Justin Trudeau, and the gun attack at Parliament Hill in October. It was discussed again in October 2015, after the federal election that made Trudeau Prime Minister. When Trudeau did not move into 24 Sussex, the Prime Minister's official residence, the main reasons cited were the fact of the aging residence needing at least ten million dollars in repairs to make it safely habitable, and the site's lack of security.

References

1. Farnsworth, Clyde (November 7, 1996). "Intruder Is Charged With Attempted Murder of Canada's Premier". New York Times. Retrieved February 22, 2017.
2. Fisher, Luke (July 8, 1996). "Chrétien Attacker Found Guilty". Maclean's. Archived from the original on September 30, 2007. Retrieved December 28, 2008.
3. Canadian Criminal Justice Today: An Introductory Text for the Twenty-first Century. Prentice Hall Allyn and Bacon Canada; 2000. ISBN 978-0-13-790411-2. p. 7.
4. "Break-in while family sleeps gives Trudeau 'pause' about heavy travel schedule". CP24, Joan Bryden, The Canadian Press, August 17, 2014
5. Caragata, Warren; Barry Came (November 20, 1995). "Security Improved at 24 Sussex". Maclean's. Archived from the original on September 27, 2007. Retrieved December 28, 2008.
6. Frank Hilliard. Home Invasion Prevention. Lulu.com; June 9, 2009. ISBN 978-0-557-04376-7. p. 8–.
7. Student of the Gun. Responder Media; ISBN 978-1-4705-0015-3. p. 16–.
8. Katrina Clarke (August 18, 2014). "Break-in at Justin Trudeau's home the latest in long-line of security breaches involving Canadian politicians". National Post. Retrieved November 5, 2023. RCMP took six to seven minutes to respond to the call. Dallaire said he intended to kill Mr. Chrétien. He was later found guilty of attempted murder but was not held criminally responsible.
9. , Defence, prosecution agree Dallare mentally ill^[usurped], June 25, 1996.
10. "André Dallaire". Archived from the original on September 24, 2015.
11. David Leyton-Brown. Canadian Annual Review of Politics and Public Affairs 1995. University of Toronto Press; July 2002. ISBN 978-0-8020-3673-5. p. 49.
12. André Dallaire, le voisin des Chrétien – Radio-Canada nouvelles Archived October 1, 2007, at the Wayback Machine
13. Bob Plamondon. The Shawinigan Fox: How Jean Chrétien Defied the Elites and Reshaped Canada. eBookIt.com; October 18, 2017. ISBN 978-1-4566-2908-3. p. 224.
14. "Terrorism in Canada: Timeline of plots, attacks, and allegations". CTV News. October 23, 2014. Retrieved January 14, 2016. 1995: Quebec sovereignty supporter Andre Dallaire entered the prime minister's residence at 24 Sussex Drive while Jean Chretien and his wife were sleeping.
15. "The World's Hottest Leader Finds a New, Unexpected Home". The Daily Beast. October 28, 2015. Retrieved January 13, 2016. A much less la-di-da memory—but one that has faded into a certain folklore about the house—is the day a man named André Dallaire somehow breached security, and got himself on the grounds, in 1995, attempting an assassination on then-Prime Minister, Jean Chrétien.
16. Althia Raj (November 23, 2016). "24 Sussex Dr. Proposal to Turn PM's Home into New 'White House' Would Have Cost $562 Million". Huffington Post.